So who makes a good thick leather apron to protect us from the pointy stuff?
To myself there in lies the problem. It is that compromise between light and comfortable Vs protection! Truly leather even though it can be hardened to point that it can be worn basically as armor, .................a incoming object at warp speed it may not stop even that. Protection from the pointy stuff, etc. Well a knife slung by a grinder, drill press, or buffer, leather even hardened may or may not be stop the offending object.
Then there is the rub to that question, have you ever tried to wear a sheet of plywood hung around your neck. The heavier and stiffer that leather needs to be, to contain pointy stuff tends too make it very uncomfortable to work with or in!!
I wear a sued/leather apron the covers everything from neck to above the ankle, it is a bit hot but not bad for being heavy! However I modified it as soon as I got it and, changed the hanging strap. it is wrapped with a terry cloth towel.
One it helps pad the weight on my neck and helps with catching any sweat at the same time. When it gets bad you take off the towel and wash or throw away!
The denim is light and only goes down to above the knee. I often have it on and forget about it! However when I set myself on fire I was grinding. The constant assault of the sparks on the bib, overcame the materials combustibility!
Now I am not saying I burst into flame but smoldering holes can be slightly uncomfortable as well!
Not to speak for JawJacker but the one that Duluth Trading makes, and they make two one of them is suppose to be made of the same material that fire hoses are made of. If you have ever messed with an old fire hose they are virtually indestructible. What usually destroys a fire hose is rotting from within or wear and tear from being drug back and forth across something! I buy some shirts from this company and their products are great, on the higher end of price but when you rate that against wear and tear not really as high as you think!!
I usually will grab the leather for grinding, especially an extended section and when using the forge. The lighter one is still top choice when headed the other direction. Comfort, ease of movement, the ability to sit down without being uncomfortable. Its kind of like life there really is no one size fits all,it a compromise ! LOL Just my take anyway!