Is this White paper micarta? If so, you won't find a much more labor intensive material to finish out. You gotta work is SLOW, with new, sharp belts, at a fairly low speed. Keep it cool (don't dunk it in water!). You can only got to about 120 on the grinder, and then everything from there is by hand, changing paper often, so an not to get those "black dots and lines" all through it. As you get finer and finer in grits, you have to change paper more often. After you put all the time an effort into it, don't make the same mistake I have in the past......trying to buff it. That just total wrecked about a days worth of hand finishing....had to go all the way back to 320, and then through the grits to 1200 to correct my mistake.
Once it's down to 1200 or so, use ONLY a brand new, clean buff, with NO compound. Then I acetone it off, and apply a single, very light coat of Tru-oil......put the tru-oil on with your fingertip, and then wipe it dry with a clean paper towel. Set the knife aside for at least two hours and your done.