Learning from mistakes.

mpcoppin

Member
I screwed up a bowie I was making from a rasp. So... I broke it to look at the grain.

Would you say this is course grain?
 

Attachments

C Craft

Well-Known Member
I would say picture straight on the grain would be better to compare it too. But No, I don't think that is a course grain. It appears to be fairly refined! Here take a look at these examples!!


MPcoppin.jpg Poor to excellent grain.png From the photo it is close to the bottom of this example. Which Is where you want to be!!

Here is another that has too large of grain in it!Large grain.png It is more like the top example in the stack!!
 

EdCaffreyMS

"The Montana Bladesmith"
Grain looks pretty large to me. It's often difficult to get the grain where it needs to be when working with recycled materials. In the case of a rasp, it could be any number of alloys.
 

JeremyBartlett

Well-Known Member
My guess would be that the rasp is case hardened. If you look at both of your pictures there is a border where the blade is the thickest at the spine that is a different color and seems to be a much finer grain. A lot of the newer farriers rasps are case hardened unlike the full hardening of the old ones.
 
Top