Buck, "IF" each element is 240vac, and you have two of these elements? Then they MUCH be wired in parallel. It says you have a 4.5" pigtail on each end of each element? If so, then try wiring 240 across only one of the elements and see how it heats. I'm sure you know how to parallel, tie the pigtails together on each end, this would put the 240 circuit wire connecting to BOTH pigtails on the end. Yes, you're cutting your wattage in half (or less). Where the element requires 240 vac across the element, you're only getting 120 vac on each element with them in series.
Nope, you still will only need the two SSR you now have.... You do have a SSR in each leg of the 240 volts? Yes, it will work with only 1 SSR, but the "proper" way to to put a SSR in each leg - like putting a switch in a 240 circuit, 1 contact will stop the circuit, but there SHOULD be a contact to open in each leg of the 240.
If you wish to call and talk on phone, I can PM you my phone number, or you can PM me your phone number.
Good luck,