For me it was between Buddy's and Benr.t's I vote for Benr.t.
Buddy's image is super clear, but the knife almost seems too close and too 'in your face' making me feel like I have to lean back to get farther away.
Ben's is super clear, and well lit. The knife is visually balanced and centered. The props aren't my favorite necessarily but overall the photo was just a touch more pleasing to look at to my eye.