The oldest recipes for rust blues are urine based, horse urine was the chosen leader, and still do an excellent job, but I prefer to work with products that at least sound less disgusting. Ever notice what a cat peaing on metal does? Many of the old masters claimed special secret ingrediants for a superior finish, but are all intended to form a layer of rust very quickly, and then stopping the rust before pitting. A solution is swabed on and the piece was put in a cabinet with very high humidity and moderate heat. All blues, except cold blueing, are based on forming a controled layer of rust, then stopping the oxidation process by boiling in water, that turns it into an oxide, which was blue. Modern caustic blues are closer to a black. You will acutually see the rust rolling up in the foam of a hot caustic blueing tank. Browning or plum, as in old muzle loaders, was the same process, but with the rust stopped by oil instead of boiling, so an oxide was never formed. It was quite common for the old classic english rust blues that are so highly prized, to have as many as a coat a day for 30 days. As Chuck has stated above, Pilkington's is the best I've found.
dennie